Xena Media Review #19 (12/08/96) - Part 4 of 4 ================== cut here ================== 7. THE TITANS The mythology notes discussed the background of the Titans. He also mentioned that Hyperion eventually married Thea. The commentary praised the special effects of the Titans and was surprised over how Gabrielle acted in the episode. 8. PROMETHEUS The mythology notes covered Prometheus. The commentary covered the cleverness of using a Hercules cross-over episode to include Xena in the myth of Hercules freeing Prometheus. The reviewer found the episode had a HTLJ feel although it had some of the characteristic violence found usually only in XWP. He also hated the bird that captured Xena. Furthermore, the reviewer stated that after 7 episodes, a non-wimpy ("If not for Xena to come to the rescue, these guys would be useful only as flower arrangers") good guy, a.k.a. Hercules, appeared in the series. But then he quickly changed his mind to except Marcus from THE PATH NOT TAKEN (#05), the town leader in THE RECKONING (#06), and Talus in DEATH IN CHAINS (#09). I disagree. I think Talus fit into the cute sensitive pubescent male that Gabrielle attracted like flies in the first season. The town leader was not a potential romantic figure for either Xena or Gabrielle (he was like the blind mystic in DREAMWORKER). However, I do agree that Marcus did represent a male who was not wimpy or evil. 9. DEATH IN CHAINS The mythology notes told us that Sisyphus was the King of Corinth and the brother of Salmoneus. This episode was based upon an actual myth, "when Death (a male) comes for Sisyphus, the king chains him up. Nobody dies until Ares comes to Death's assistance." The reviewer also noted that Death was the twin brother of Hypnos, the god of sleep NOT Hades sister. In the commentary the writer picked up on the Kevorkian "MICHIGAN" connection. I am working on unraveling the GREAT MICHIGAN conspiracy which XWP seems to be a critical part of. After criticizing some perceived plot-elements, the writer obsessed on Kate Hodge, who played Death. 10. HOOVES & HARLOTS In the synopsis, "right of caste" was misspelled. In the mythology notes, the writer repeated the "myth" that Amazon meant breastless woman and that the Amazons cut off their right breast so they could use the bow better. That is ridiculous. Just ask any female archer. The reviewer also stated, "Consistent with Xena (and Hercules, for that matter) standards, this episode features Amazons as buxom as are ever likely to be portrayed. Centaurs, of course, are half-man, half- horse creatures that on the whole are savage, wild, and lawless." Thinking back on AS DARKNESS FALLS (HTLJ #06) and the Hercules movie where a bad, bad centaur absconds with Hercules' wife, the centaurs were portrayed in a not so nice a way. But, in HOOVES AND HARLOTS (#10), THE OUTCAST (HTLJ #18), and ORPHAN OF WAR (#25), the centaurs were presented as noble and honorable creatures. Perhaps Centaurs come in all moral flavors? In the comments section, the writer lauded (1) the special effects as to the centaurs; (2) Renee O'Connor's performance; and (3) the great scene where Xena tried to get Gabrielle to make the royal challenge without speaking to her directly. The writer poo-pooed (1) how quickly Gabrielle learned the art of the staff over the next few episodes; and (2) the Amazon justice system. The writer was obviously a male! Transcription by Stacy Van Stipdonk. EXCERPT: 1. SINS OF THE PAST... ...COMMENTS: The series premiere is entertaining, but the tone is more like an episode of Hercules than the Xenas to come. Gabrielle's patter, her encounter with a Cyclops on the way to Amphipolis, and the goofy final battle all combine to overpower any of the grimmer aspects of Xena's attempt at absolution. Nevertheless, those underlying darker elements permeate the show. Xena's homecoming and reunion with her mother lack the fanfare viewers generally expect with scenes featuring the protagonist. The uneasiness of the towns people allow new viewers to know that something is amiss, even without the background of having watched the Hercules episodes. All in all, an adequate beginning.... (Picture of Xena and Gabrielle from "Sins of the Past". Caption: Xena is reluctant to allow Gabrielle to accompany her on her travels. Picture of Draco pointing a sword at Xena's neck while she reclines. Caption: Draco challenges Xena to team up with him in "Sins of the Past.") ...2. CHARIOTS OF WAR... COMMENTS: This episode contains one of the most gruesome scenes of the series. Xena has been shot in her side with an arrow, but it did not go all the way through. Darius has to push the arrow through to the other side, then break the shaft in two and pull out each end. Lawless's effective grimaces of pain makes the scene difficult to watch (even though the viewer doesn't really see anything gruesome). The episode seems to argue for a "peace through strength" ideology (as such thinking used to be called years ago). The villagers were taking a pacifist stance and getting annihilated. They may have been offended at Xena's war-like nature, but she saved them from a life of servitude. On a related note, the two prominent sensitive-male types (Darius and Sphaerus) are okay for about the first five minutes. Then it's time to shoot them both -- especially Sphaerus, who overplays his "sensitivity" excessively. How did he ever become feared in the first place? On the other hand, this is one of O'Connor's better performances as Gabrielle, aided by some wonderful dialogue. Her attempt to avoid being hassled by a "swarthy stranger" by jumping into Sphaerus's lap ("Pretend you know me." "No problem," he responds) is amusing, as is her glance up at Xena during her comment about becoming some "lonely, pathetic woman" without a husband. (See "Gabrielle the Grammarian," page 10.) ...3. DREAMWORKER... ...COMMENTS: "Dreamworker" is a quintessential Xena episode, combining mythology, Gabrielle's silliness, lots of action, and a rather dark, grim undercurrent. Xena's Dream Passage sequences are creepy and effective, and two scenes stand out -- when she meets her first victim with his throat slashed, and earlier, her confrontation with many of her victims who begin telling her their names. It becomes an extraordinary multi-layered incident, not only telling the viewer about Xena's ruthless past history but about her past psychology: her victims were merely nameless, faceless masses. Xena is distressed to have those victims personalized. (Of course, she's already renounced those activities.) Xena's past is what gives the series its edge and separates it from a fairly straight-forward adventure series (such as in the Hercules vein). Many later episodes downplay this aspect, substituting violence as the "edge." Psychological intrigue, however, is much more interesting (though undoubtedly more difficult to write). ...4. CRADLE OF HOPE... ... COMMENTS: Moses meets Pandora?!? Only in the world of Xena. The placement of the baby in a basket in the river, and the subsequent attempt to kill that child, is obviously inspired by the events recorded in Exodus 2. In Gregor we're presented with yet another wimpy, "sensitive" male leader, although he's not as bad as what we saw in the second episode. What's with Xena's hands of steel?? How can she grab a sharp sword with her hand? (During her battle with Nemos at the end, she stops his lunging sword with her bare hands,) She does this again later in the series (see "The Black Wolf," for instance). This episode introduces a series of weird disclaimers that often appear during the end credits. The one for this episode reads, "No Babies were harmed during the production of this motion picture." ...5. THE PATH NOT TAKEN... ... COMMENTS: Although Xena is an episodic, rather than serial, series, "The Path Not Taken" makes numerous references to "Cradle of Hope." In fact, conflicting accounts of the central element of that episode's story play a critical role in "Path." In order to work her way into Mezentius's trust, Xena dismisses reports of her renounced warrior status and claims that she ransomed Gregor's child. Later, it's learned that she rescued the baby, and that's the beginning of the end of her deception. That aside, there's nothing that particularly distinguishes this episode. It's an average, though solid, hour of fun. This episode did make us wonder about one thing in particular. Xena refuses to accept payment for her rescue. In fact, she always refuses payment, and Gabrielle doesn't bring in any money. Since neither have employment, how are they able to buy food and supplies? Marcus also appears in the episode "Mortal Beloved" later in the season.... ...6. THE RECKONING... ...COMMENTS: This is an interesting episode in that Xena's immediate conflict is not with a group of evil men, but (for the most part) a well-meaning community of farmers who legitimately believe that she has murdered their friends. And the town leader, for a change, breaks the mold that the male characters in the series were beginning to fall into, either (1) the bad guys, who are always irrational, aggressive, and downright nasty, or (2) the good guys, who are passive, unwilling to take a stand, and generally not too intelligent. Just as "Cradle of Hope" seems partially inspired by the story of Moses in the Old Testament, "The Reckoning" brings to mind the incident in the New Testament where Satan tempts a weakened Christ. This parallel might seem like a bit of a stretch, although Robert Tapert told Sci-Fi Entertainment, "For both shows [Hercules and Xena], we'll start to raise a few stories from the Bible." On the other hand, this parallel (and others) should not be over-emphasized or over-analyzed. Xena is certainly not an allegory, and we doubt that it employs, or even attempts, symbolism. The writers simply pull story elements from a wide variety of sources for whatever occasion suits their needs.... ...7. THE TITANS... ...COMMENTS: This moderately -- enjoyable episode features some of the best special effects of the series. Actually, much of the effects on the Titans are created through careful use of camera angles. These combine with slow character movements and pounding sound effects as they walk to create a convincing illusion of great size. The shots in which the Titans and mortals are in the same frame also look good. Finally, one amusing, well done scene has Xena and Gabrielle standing beside a large brick wall. Suddenly, a giant foot comes smashing through from the other side, throwing them several yards! Perhaps the weirdest aspect of this show occurs when Gabrielle discovers she has three Titans to do her bidding. Suddenly she becomes abrupt and rude -- completely out of character for her.... ...8. PROMETHEUS... GRAPHIC: (1) Picture of Hercules and Xena, caption: Xena rejoins an old friend -- although their roles are more adversarial in "Prometheus."; (2) Picture of Hercules and Xena smiling, caption: Xena and Hercules watch as Prometheus frees himself. ...COMMENTS: This is a clever use of Hercules's guest appearance, reworking the Prometheus legend to include Xena! Overall, the episode has more of a Hercules-ish feel, such as a souvenir shop near Vulcan Mountain. On the other hand, the episode also contains perhaps the most gruesome scene of the series (topping even Xena's arrow injury in "Chariots of War"). A man's throat gets slashed, cutting his windpipe. Xena inserts a straw that will allow him to breathe until the injury heals. Vulcan Mountain contains some great traps that recall the first Indiana Jones movie. Unfortunately, the effects of the bird carrying Xena are not so special. Finally the world of Xena has a strong, masculine male character who is on the side of good -- Hercules. (Two men, if we include Iolaus.) As we mentioned before, the males generally fall into only two categories. There are the "masculine," strong, assertive men, usually in positions of authority. And they're almost always evil. They're the villains. Then there are the "good guys": passive, sensitive, and weak. If not for Xena to come to the rescue, these guys would be useful only as flower arrangers. Fortunately, Hercules and Iolaus break this tendency in the show (along with, to a lesser extent, Marcus in "The Path Not Taken" and "Mortal Beloved," the town leader in "The Reckoning," and Talus in "Death in Chains"). This episode has the second weird disclaimer during the end credits: "Iolaus was harmed during the production of this motion picture. However, the Green Egg Men went on to live long and prosperous lives."... ...9. DEATH IN CHAINS... GRAPHIC: Caption: Kate Hodge plays the ghostly Celesta in "Death in Chains." ...COMMENTS: Is "Death in Chains" a weird, pro-death episode? Where else can someone find so many examples of people looking forward to death for various reasons? (However, J.E. Zimmerman notes in his dictionary of mythology that "in many literary allusions [Death] is presented as a healer and remover of pain.") This must be Dr. Kevorkian's favorite episode. That aside, the idea of imprisoning death is an interesting one, and this episode explores some of the consequences. Unfortunately, many of the plot elements aren't given much explanation. (Why does Celesta "die" when her candle is extinguished? What does it mean for her to die, anyway? How is it so easy for her to be bound? How secure is a castle in which Talus and Gabriel can gain easy access through a "hidden back entrance"?) Nevertheless, it's an effective, moody episode. Kate Hodge is good as the more-or-less ethereal Celesta. (The actress might be remembered by some viewers as the co-star of the X-Files-ish British show She-Wolf of London a few years ago. She currently plays Gretchen on Louie.)... ...10. HOOVES & HARLOTS... ...COMMENTS: This is quite a fun episode, and, for a change, the special effects are pretty good -- the centaurs actually come off as more-or-less believable. The real stand-out here, though, is Renee O'Connor in one of her best episodes. Her portrayal of Gabrielle in the role of Amazon princess is perfect -- a combination of awe, surprise, fun, awkwardness, good effort, and seriousness. Perhaps the best line is when Xena questions Gabrielle about her activities, and she responds, "I'm an Amazon princess?" Actually, the way O'Connor delivers the line, it's half a question, half a statement exactly the way a somewhat -- confused Gabrielle would deliver the answer. Another wonderful scene comes near the end with some great interaction between Lawless and O'Connor. Gabrielle must fight the Queen -- unless Gabrielle's champion fights in her place. Xena understands the procedure for accepting the battle; Gabrielle doesn't. Xena manages to convey the plan through subtle hints and raised eyebrows. O'Connor does a good job of portraying Gabrielle's slight confusion that, following Xena's lead, gradually moves to understanding. The Amazons train Gabrielle to fight with a staff -- a skill she utilizes in many later episodes. Before this, Gabrielle adhered to Xena's instruction to talk her way out of a conflict or to run. Hereafter, when Gabrielle would inject herself into the fights, Xena would not complain. In fact, to look at the choreography on some of the battle scenes to follow, Gabrielle became very good very quickly (almost too quickly). One final note. The Amazons obviously have a low regard for justice in this episode. They're ready to execute a centaur without any evidence to connect him to the killing. Even the circumstantial evidence is slight. The end-credits disclaimer: "No Males, Centaurs or Amazons were harmed during the production of this motion picture " GRAPHIC: Posed picture of Xena holding her sword. [264] 05-01-96 SPECTRUM. Vol. 1 No. 5. Page 10. 474 words. "Gabrielle the Grammarian" COMMENTARY: As XWP progressed through the first season, the character of Gabrielle emerged. She went from comedy relief and second banana, to full helpmeet and companion to the Warrior Princess. This sidebar article listed SPECTRUM's favorite Gabrielle "one-liners". Transcription by Stacy Van Stipdonk. REPRINT: Xena's sidekick is certainly appropriately named. Gabrielle can, if nothing else, gab. She has proven an ability to talk her way out of anything, plus an ability to chatter endlessly about nothing at all. Here are some of our favorite lines from the first half of the season: Gabrielle wants to go with Xena and be taught by her. Xena says she travels alone. Gabrielle: "You can't leave me here." Xena: "Why?" Gabrielle: "Did you see the guy they want me to marry?" Xena: "He looks like a gentle soul. That's rare in a man." Gabrielle: "It's not the gentle part I have a problem with -- it's the dull, stupid part." ["Sins of the Past"] Gabrielle prepares to sneak out at night to join Xena. Gabrielle: "I'm going to join up with Xena." Lila, her sister (laughs): "Are you serious?" Gabrielle: "Absolutely. I'm going to be a warrior, like her." Sister: "A warrior? Gabrielle, I can beat you up." Gabrielle: "Yeah, but you're very strong for your age. Lila, you know I'm different from everybody else in this town." Sister: "I know you're crazy." Gabrielle: "Well, call it whatever you like." ["Sins of the Past"] Gabrielle is interested in buying a small sword. The salesman picks up a small dagger: "It's a breast dagger." Gabrielle: "You mean it's designed to pierce the breast into the heart of your enemy!" Salesman: "No, not quite." Later, Xena confiscates Gabrielle's breast dagger. Gabrielle: "Ha! It's not like your breasts aren't dangerous enough. That was a joke! You can laugh!" ["Dreamworker"] Gabrielle tells Xena about the man (unbeknown to her, a warlord) she has a crush on: Gabrielle: "I have no way of finding this guy. What if I'm supposed to intertwine with him and have kids? Now I'll wind up some lonely, pathetic woman like [looks at Xena] -- never mind." ["Chariots of War"] Gabrielle has been selected to be the bride of Morpheus. Gabrielle: "Bride? Morpheus? No, you've got the wrong girl. Take my word for it -- I'm not the wifey type. Well I sleep late, I don't know a lick about housework, and children -- I mean, look at these hip bones! No way!" Mystic: "None of that matters to Morpheus." Gabrielle: "Really? Well what does matter? I've got lots of faults." ["Dreamworker"] Gabrielle and Xena talk: Xena: "I'm not sure how [Iolaus] feels about me now." Gabrielle: "And what about Hercules?" Xena: What about him?" Gabrielle: "You're not much for girl talk, are you? Of course, you're not like most girls." ["Prometheus"] Xena challenges the Amazon Queen to the death. Gabrielle: "Don't you think she [Xena] knows what she's doing? You haven't seen her fight. Now I have seen her fight a lot!" Amazon (to Xena): "She's annoying. How do you put up with her?" Gabrielle: "Hey! She puts up with me fine!" ["Hooves and Harlots"] [265] 05-01-96 SCI-FI UNIVERSE. Vol 2. No. 15. Page 37. --- words. "Babes in Boyland. When it comes to science fiction, why does ERA stand for 'Exploitation Roles Always'?" By Amanda Finch. COMMENTARY: XWP was mentioned in passing as an example of the exploitation of women ("For every appropriately attired Agent Scully on The X-Files (who, lacking the traditional attributes of the TV sexpot, has watched as her co-star has gotten the lion's share of publicity), female science fiction fans face seven or eight leather-thonged 'warrior princesses' (Xena) or Pamela Anderson's cleavage fighting crime in black leather (Barb Wire)."). Some issues raised in this article were discussed specifically in the XWP context in the Ms. Magazine (July/August 1996) article "Xena: She's Big, Tall, Strong--and Popular" [tentative XMR322]. The author may have been referring to the episode "Hooves and Harlots." This article was discussed in relative detail in my introduction to XMR #03 [with emphasis on Xena: Warrior Princess] and RIF (Resistance is Futile Netzine) #55 [with emphasis on Star Trek]. I have rewritten in part the XMR #03 version below. XWP: A PRE-MYCENAEAN BAYWATCH? SCI-FI UNIVERSE magazine, trying to be the bad-boy periodical on the science fiction periodical world, was created several years ago as the SF version of FILM THREAT. FILM THREAT was an uneven but horribly fun attempt at movie criticism. What set FILM THREAT apart from the other film magazines was the uncontrolled exuberance of the critics. You knew that these people loved every minute of what they were doing. They loved being social critics and taking the essence of some grade Z schlock and painfully extracting both the microcosm and microcosm of human existence from it. It was good stuff, especially if you were a college student, away from home, trying to create a cool environment for your life. Chris Gore was behind FILM THREAT at that time and he started to concentrate more and more on science fiction. Finally the publishers said, cut the SF stuff and put it in another magazine. Thus SCI-FI UNIVERSE was born. SCI-FI UNIVERSE immediately carved itself out as the Anti-STARLOG. In fact, if both magazines were ever touch, they would surely destroy each other. Good college fun. After awhile, Mark Altman took over the editorial control, Chris Gore went back to FILM THREAT, and SCI- FI UNIVERSE changed. But that is another story...my story concerns the most recent issue May 1996. The SCI-FI UNIVERSE of May 1996 sported a "Play it Again PAM" cover with Ms. Pamela Lee nee Anderson busting out all over. On page 37, the article "Babes in Boyland" appeared. It was a scathing (and I mean scathing for SF media) indictment of how SF TV and movies treated women. The article made a passing reference to XWP. On page 37, column one, Amanda Finch wrote, "Compared with most sci-fi offerings, however, the women of Trek are dressed like spinster librarians. For every appropriately attired Agent Scully on The X-Files (who, lacking the traditional attributes of the TV sexpot, has watched as her co-star has gotten the lion's share of publicity), female science fiction fans face seven or eight leather-thonged 'warrior princesses' (Xena) or Pamela Anderson's cleavage fighting crime in black leather (Barb Wire)." I wish to make three comments. First, the writer has thrown XWP into the "bad" column. One of the problems of generalization is that it...um...generalizes. I have seen this complaint about XWP from other reviewers and writers. The most recent assault being the insipid observation that being able to take the armor off of the Xena action figure somehow promotes prurience. Such critics categorically state that Xena is sexist and exploitative. Well, it is. But (there's always a but!) Xena is a satire of the genre. The "saving graces" of Xena are the twists that the producers and writers have added to Xena: the women are self-sufficient (no regular male character who rescues them; no regular love interest); Xena competes equally and usually wins against her foes, male or female, just as Gabrielle does in her more idealized intellectual way; relationships between women are explored; and so on. If XWP was meant to be a Pre- Mycenaean Baywatch, it is not playing to the logical adolescent male audience. It may be getting his interest, but it is clearly not focusing on it. Second, I was struck by the irony of finding this article in SCI-FI UNIVERSE. A simple leaf-through of any of the issues show that SCI-FI UNIVERSE strongly subscribes to exhibiting women in various stages of undress (usually concentrating on the bust area - thus giving us more insight into Mr. Altman's tastes? For some reason it reminds me of David Letterman...). However, this is an epidemic affliction with most popular media Science Fiction magazines. Compared to many others, SCI-FI UNIVERSE is like a "spinster librarian" (but, whoa, watch out if she gets married and is exposed to the manly virtues). If we point the finger at one, we must point it to all. It would be facile to blame it on the fact that 99% of all publishers and editors are men. But would it be any more realistic to accept that this type of "journalism" sells magazines like hotcakes? This blames the consumer, who is merely buying what is offered...which is offered because that's what the consumer supposedly only will buy. Catch-22. Third, I have come to the conclusion that any type of self-reflection is better than none at all. SCI-FI UNIVERSE must be applauded for running the article. Social change fumbles along at a snail's pace. At some point a society reaches critical mass and suddenly can no longer accept what was done without question in the past. We see this happening today in respect to race relations and the balance between men and women in society, to name two. I like to think that XWP, mired with one foot in the old and one foot in the new, is merely one of many reflections of a society in transition. I like the show, so I think of it as an advancement, not a step backwards. Art reflects the society from which it was made, but art also can transcend the very same society. XWP promotes a world where a woman can successfully make her way depending upon her skills and intellect and she can compete without being subjected to sexual violence, archaic social limitations, and arbitrary social codes. If she has to walk around in leather and in next to nothing, well, I can live with that. For now. EXCERPT: [sent out for transcription] ------------- THE BACK PAGE ------------- Issue #20 will contain annotations #266 through #285, dated from 05-02-96 to 05-14-96. It is scheduled to be released 12-13-96. PREFERRED CITATION: When citing an annotated review, use the format: XMR:007. This example means Xena Media Review [issue #01], annotation #007. BACK ISSUES: Back issues of XMR are available at the XMR Archive on the IAXS web page: http://www.teleport.com/~gater/IAXS/IAXS.html REPRINT POLICY: Permission to use, copy and distribute Xena Media Review (XMR), or parts thereof, by electronic means for any non-profit purpose is hereby granted, provided that both the above copyright notice and this permission notice appear in all copies of the newsletter itself, and that proper credit is given for any excerpts. Any other format or purpose for distribution requires permission of the author. Reproducing XMR or parts thereof by any means implies full agreement to the above non-profit-use clause. SOLICITATIONS FOR FUTURE NEWSLETTERS Send cites, references, articles, annotations, and/or submissions to ktaborn@lightspeed.net. XMR is a non-profit fan publication. The editors retain editorial control and reprint privileges over the submitted materials and reserve the right to use the material in whatever way they deem appropriate. Submitted materials will not be returned to the sender. DISCLAIMER: XMR (Xena Media Review) is a free non- profit informational release. XMR in no way intends to challenge, disregard or profit from any of the original copyright holders of the material excerpted, reprinted, or referred to (including but not limited to MCA, Universal, Renaissance Pictures, and any other rightful and legal copyright holder). This newsletter is an academic and educational pursuit to archive, annotate, and study the media response to Xena: Warrior Princess (a television production from MCA/Universal/ Renaissance) and the actresses Lucy Lawless and Renee O'Connor, especially in the light of popular culture and the influence of mass media. XMR exercises its right to quote, excerpt or reprint as allowed under the law in order to review and discuss the media reports cited and annotated herein. XMR is distributed free of charge. Only national/international major media released in electronic form are considered for inclusion. Banner graphic by Colleen Stephan. This is an All Talk No Action Publication. Copyright 1996 by Kym Masera Taborn. Check out the free netzine called "Resistance is Futile," a Star Trek parody and all things Borgish newsletter which is issued every 19 days and has been published since 1992 (the Borg jokes just keep on coming!). Request a free subscription at ktaborn@lightspeed.net. Check out the back issues at WEB SITE: http://www.startrek.in-trier.de/rif/ ================== cut here ================== END FILE